Re: Sent request for Debt Validation and this is what i got...
Most judges at both the federal and state levels would most likely rule that what they sent you was sufficient to comply with the requirements of FDCPA. However, in Fields v. Wilburlawfirm Judge Kenneth Minh of the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed. The case has become somewhat of a landmark decision in that at least 35 attorneys have referenced the case in their motions and briefs.
But what about the agreement you have with the credit card company? You should try to make them produce that or at least a readable copy certified by the maker to be a true and correct copy of the original. While on the surface of the matter that may not seem important and you may or may not be able to force them to produce such a copy even though you use Duces Tecum.
Getting a copy of the agreement can be vitally important to winning in court in many cases. There are always terms and conditions that may be useful to you so you should make every effort to make sure the court backs you up on your demands for production of that document.
Also, when you go to court make certain that you have previously arranged with the clerk of the court to have a court reporter present and taking notes unless the court provides that service for you through audio or video transcripts. Never go to court without a transcription being available.
Now let's move on to your canned validation letter.
While it may not hurt to ask for the above I find no place in FDCPA that says they have to provide that to you as a part of validation
| Provide me with copies of any papers that show I agreed to pay what you say I owe; | Nowhere in FDCPA does it state that debt collectors are required to prove that the statute of limitations has not expired. Demanding it is rather silly because if the case goes to court and you plead a statute of limitations defense you will have to prove that it has indeed ran out on them. The only way to hopefully make them prove they filed timely is through use of your 5 discovery tools.
| Prove the Statute of Limitations has not expired on this account | None of that is required under FDCPA either. Canned validation letters found on the internet make their users look stupid. One should never use them in a useless attempt to teach the other fellow how smart the debtor is. Never attempt to teach the other fellow how smart you are. The whole point is to learn how smart they are, not teach them how smart you are. The less you say the better off you are.
| Show me that you are licensed to collect in my state |
Provide me with your license numbers and Registered Agent
Many of the letters one finds on the internet also use the phrase "cease & desist" in one way or another. It is an attempt to create a partial cease & desist but use of that phrase in any way is patently stupid because nowhere in FDCPA is there any provision for a partial cease & desist. It is all or nothing and use of the phrase can easily be turned into disasterous results for the sender. FDCPA clearly provides for use of another phrase that accomplshes the desired results without those 3 possibly fatal to your case words. You should never accept anything that anyone says (including me) as being the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth without doing your homework and thoroughly checking it out for yourself. Blindly accepting things you see on the internet and blindly accepting the truth of the statements based on how logical they seem can and probably will be used against you in a court of law sooner or later. Use what people tell you on the internet as a starting point for your investigations and nothing more.
Don't even trust what lawyers and judges tell you as being true and correct. They are only human beings and are often wrong in what they say. If you doubt the veracity of that statement just ask a judge the wrong question and you will get the right answer to the wrong question every time.
RECOMMENDED READING Subscribe to Creditwrench
Subscribe to Creditwrench mailing list. It is free and very informative. .
See all my questions and how I answered them. Just enter your email address in the box below, choose whether you want individual emails or just a daily digest of all messages posted each day. You can unsubscribe any time you wish
↑ Grab this Headline Animator
- FDCPA EXPERT
- Reverse phone number look up
- List of community property states
- How to answer a summons
LISTEN TO THESE CREDITWRENCH STUDENTS CHAT ON OUR FRIDAY NIGHT CONFERENCE CALLS.
- Mike JM tells about his experiences in federal court
- Mike JM tells about Greentree Financial case.
- Listen to this student tell how he got $10,000 from a federal case against Capital One
- Mark in Rhode Island gets settlement offer
- Statute of Limitations for all states
- How to set up your hard drive for creditwrench files.
Makes them easy to find.
The Creditwrench conference calls will start this coming Friday evening at 7 P.M. Central time. It is free and open to the public. There is no cost or obligation other than what it may cost you for the phone call itself. You can join in and ask questions or just listen or whatever you want to do.
Dial-in Number: (712) 432-1601
Access code: 508548#
You might also want to visit our message forum at http://consumers.creditwrench.com to get answers to questions you need answered before next Friday night.
Try this great new search engine!
It pays you cash money for every search you do!
How about a search engine on steroids? It acts like an RSS feed for most other search engines. Between these two you shouldn't ever need anything else. Use these two for all your searches. You will be glad you did.
Addictomatic Search engine
This Sigline updates constantly! Try it!
Creditwrench - The lethal weapon against debt collectors
(405) 237-2174- CALL ANYTIME
(405) 684-9297 FAX NUMBER
(405) 227-9423 - CALL ANYTIME
(405) 384-4508 - CALL ANYTIME
If you click on the banner below and sign up you get $10.00 cash money just for signing up. It is another payment service just like Paypal but much better. Give it a try. You have nothing to lose and at least $10.00 to gain.
If you liked this article please consider a small donation to the author. You can sign up and get the $10 cash and use a buck or so to tip the author with. Costs you nothing that way.
Before you go, stop and think about this. Its all about fighting poverty. Although we may go through our daily routines without realinzed it, the number of homeless people is growing rapidly. While many of the homeless have drug or alchol problems many are simply people who are homeless because of mortgage foreclosures and other financially related problems. I have armed you with a great deal of information about how to deal with debt collectors who can easily beat you out of your hard earned cash and make you the next victim of poverty. Help fight poverty (yours) by keeping your cash in your pocket. Creditwrench teaches you how to do exactly that.
a simple question regarding the Discovery phase